Care facilities for Germans in Thailand and Poland: making old age care abroad legitimate
Article Sidebar
Main Article Content
Abstract
This article looks at old age care facilities abroad that target people who live in Germany. Such facilities have been established in Southeast Asia (mainly Thailand) and in Eastern Europe (mainly Poland). Given that they challenge central guiding orientations for old age care in Germany, considerable criticisms are levelled at them, and their use is viewed with distinct scepticism. Nevertheless, some of these facilities succeed in sustaining considerable demand from Germany over quite a few years. In this article, we therefore ask what strategies and arguments they use to make them a legitimate option for people in Germany and to be established on the German market. Based on two case studies of an old age facility in Thailand
and Poland, we will show how they skilfully position themselves as “better” options for residential care even though their strategies considerably vary and result in very different models of old age care. Drawing on neo-institutional organisation theories, we will show how these strategies are essential for the facilities’ emergence as new players in the care market for older people from Germany.
Metrics
Article Details
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial 4.0 International License.
Since 2020 the International Journal of Ageing and Later Life uses a Creative Commons: Attribution license, which allows users to distribute the work and to reform or build upon it without the author's permission. Full reference to the author must be given.
References
Arend, S. (2017). Sorge(n)volle Zustände. In S. Arend & T. Klie (eds.), Wer pflegt Deutschland. Transnationale Pflegekräfte – Analysen, Erfahrungen, Konzept [Who Cares in Germany. Transnatinal Care Workers – Analysis, Experiences, Conzept] (pp. 11–30). Hannover: Vincentz Network.
Behr, T. (ed.). (2015). Aufbruch Pflege. Hintergründe – Analysen – Entwicklungsperspektiven [Changing Old Age Care. Backgrounds, Analysis, Development Perspectives]. Wiesbaden: Springer.
Bender, D. (2015). ‘Doing discourse for moving care recipients’. Pflegeheime für deutschsprachige demenzkranke Menschen in Thailand ‘salonfähig’ machen [To make old age care homes for German-speaking peo¬ple with Dementia in Thailand respectable]. Zeitschrift für Qualitative Forschung 16(1): 73–98.
Bender, D., Hollstein, T. & Schweppe, C. (2017). The emergence of care facilities in Thailand for older German-speaking people: Structural backgrounds and facility operators as transnational actors. European Journal of Ageing 14(4): 365–374.
Bender, D., Hollstein, T. & Schweppe, C. (2018). Old age facilities for German-speaking people in Thailand – A new facet of international migration in old age. Journal of Ethnic and Migration Studies. Published online: 12 Sep 2018. doi: 10.1080/1369183X.2018.1521266.
Böcker, A., Horn, V. & Schweppe, C. (2017). Old age care regimes and the emergence of transnational long-term care arrangements for the elderly. In L. Good Gingrich & S. Köngeter (eds.), Transnational Social Policy, Social Welfare in a World on the Move (pp. 222–242). New York: Routledge.
Corbin, J. & Strauss, A. (2008). Basics of Qualitative Research. Techniques and Procedures for Developing Grounded Theory (3rd ed.). Los Angeles, CA: Sage.
Engelmann, D., Gohde, J., Künzel, G. & Schmidt, S. (2013). Gute Pflege vor Ort. Das Recht auf eigenständiges Leben im Alter [Good Local Old Age Care. The Right to Live Indpendently in Old Age]. Bonn: Friedrich-Ebert-Stiftung.
Eurobarometer (2007). Health and long-term care in European Union. Special Eurobarmeter 283/Wave 67.3. Brussels: European Commission.
Görgen, T. (2017). Wissen über das Phänomen Gewalt in der Pflege [Knowledge about violence in old age care]. In Zentrum für Qualität in der Pflege (ed.), ZQP Report. Gewaltprävention in der Pflege [ZQP Report. Preventing Violence in Old Age Care] (pp. 8–12). Berlin. Available on https://www.zqp.de/wp-content/uploads/Report_Gewalt_Praeven-tion_Pflege_Alte_Menschen.pdf (Accessed: April 23, 2018).
Grassberger, M. & Püschel, K. (eds.). (2013). Forensische Gerontologie. Gewalt gegen alte Menschen [Forensic Gerontology. Violence against Old People]. Springer: Wiesbaden.
Großmann, S. & Schweppe, C. (2018). Just like in Germany, only better? Old-age care facilities in Poland for people from Germany and the question of legitimacy. Ageing & Society 1–19. doi: 10.1017/S0144686X18001290.
Hahn, A. (2012). Jauch-Talk zur Altenpflege. Darf man Oma nach Thailand abschieben? [Jauch-Talk about Old Age Care. May One Deport Granma to Thailand?] Available on https://www.bild.de/politik/inland/guen¬ther-jauch/darf-man-oma-nach-thailand-abschieben-27038224.bild. html (Accessed: May 22, 2018).
Horn, V., Schweppe, C., Bender, D. & Hollstein, T. (2016). “Moving (for) elder care abroad”: The fragile promises of old age care facilities for elderly Germans in Thailand. In V. Horn & C. Schweppe (eds.), Trans¬national Aging. Current Insights and Future Challenges (pp. 163–177). New York: Routledge.
Jaisuekun, J. (2017). A search for a better life. Economic motivation of the German relocation to Pattaya. Walailak Journal of Social Science 10(2): 41–80.
Jaisuekun, K. & Sunanta, S. (2016). Lifestyle migration in Thailand. A case study of German migrants in Pattaya. Thammasat Review 19(2): 89–103.
Jansen, B. & Klie, T. (1999). Häuslichkeit [Domesticity]. In B. Jansen, F. Karl, H. Radebold & R. Schmitz-Scherzer (eds.), Soziale Gerontologie [Social Gerontology] (pp. 521–539). Weinheim: Beltz.
Jöstl, J. & Wieser, B. (2011). Auf der Suche nach dem Paradies? Einblicke in eine Studie zu “Amenity Migration” in Cha-am und Hua-Hin, Thailand [Sercing for paradies. Insights into a study on “amenity migration” in Cha-am Hua-Hin, Thailand]. ASEAS Austrian Journal of South-East Asian Studies 4(1): 166–172.
Konpress and Emnid. (2013). Pflege im Ausland – im Alter ins Exil? [Old Age Care Abroad – Aging in Exil?]. Available on http://konpress. de/wp-content/uploads/Emnid-Repr%C3%A4sentativbefra¬gung-Pflege-im-Ausland-final.pdf (Accessed: June 13, 2018).
Krawietz, J. (2010). Pflegearbeit unter Legitimierungsdruck – Vermittlunggsagenturen im transnationalen Organisationsfeld [Old age care work under pressure of legitimation. recruitment agencies in a trans¬national organizational field]. In K. Scheiwe & J. Krawietz (eds.), Transnationale Sorgearbeit. Rechtliche Rahmenbedingungen und gesellschaftliche Praxis [Transnational Care Work. Legal Frameworks and Social Practice] (pp. 249–276). Wiesbaden: Springer.
Krawietz, J. (2014). Pflege grenzüberschreitend organisieren. Eine Studie zur Vermittlung von Care-Arbeit [Organizing Care across Borders. A Study on Recruitung Care Work]. Frankfurt am Main: Mabuse.
Kresge, N. (2013). ‘Grandma export’ exposes Germany’s struggle with care. The Japan Times. Available on: https://www.japantimes.co.jp/ news/2013/09/24/world/social-issues-world/grandma-export-exposes-germanys-struggle-with-care/#.WwPsvkxuLNM (Accessed: May 22, 2018).
Leifeld, U. (2002). “But They Don’t Know My View.” Interkulturelle Kom¬munikationskonflikte thailändischer und deutscher Flugbegleiter am Arbeitsplatz [Intercultural Communication Conflicts between Thai and German Flight Attendants at Work]. Münster: LIT.
Loew, P. (2017). Unsichtbar? Polinnen und Polen in Deutschland – die zweitgrößte Zuwanderergruppe [Invisible? Poles in Germany – The second largest immigration group]. Available on: http://www.bpb.de/gesellschaft/migration/kurzdossiers/256398/polnische-diaspora (Accessed: January 20, 2019).
Maybaum, M. (2017). Hilfe bei der Pflege daheim: “Dann holt Euch doch ‘ne Polin.” [Help for Old Age Care at Home: “Just Get a Pole”]. Available on https:// www.nrz.de/region/dann-holt-euch-doch-ne-polin-id210073997.html (Accessed: February 22, 2018).
Mischke, C., Koppitz, A. L., Dreizler, J. & Händler-Schuster, D. (2015). Eintritt ins Pflegeheim: Das Erleben der Entscheidung aus der Perspektive der Pflegeheimbewohnerinnen und Pflegeheimbewohner [Entering a nursing home: Experiencing the decision from the perspective of nursing home residents]. Journal für Qualitative Forschung in Pflege- und Gesundheitswissenschaft 2(1): 72–81.
Newerla, A. (2012). Verwirrte pflegen, verwirrte Pflege? Handlungsprobleme und Handlungsstrategien in der stationären Pflege von Menschen mit Demenz – eine ethnographische Studie [To Care for the Confused, Confused Care? Problems and Strategies in Residential Care of People with Dementia. An Ethnographic Study]. Berlin: LIT Verlag.
Pflege-Report. (2017). Pflegeheimbewohner erhalten zu viele Psychopharmaka [Residents of old age care homes receive too many psychotropic drugs]. Available on http://aok-bv.de/presse/pres¬semitteilungen/2017/index_18363.html (Accessed: August 30, 2018).
PKV (Verband der privaten Krankenkassen). (2018). Die Finanzierungslücke der Pflegeversicherung ist erneut gewachsen [The Funding Gap of the Long- Term Care Insurance has Grown Again]. Available on https://www. pkv.de/presse/meldungen/finanzierungsluecke-der-pflegeversi¬cherung-ist-erneut-gewachsen (Accessed: September 22, 2018).
Posener, A. (2014). Deutschland wird Weltmeister im Oma-Export [Germany will be the Champion of Exporting Granma]. Available on https://www. welt.de/kultur/article133590183/Deutschland-wird-Weltmeister-im- Oma-Export.html (Accessed: June 28, 2018).
Prantl, H. (2012). Die verrückte Idee vom Greisen-Export. Pflegeheime im Ausland [The Crazy Idea of Exporting Old People. Old Age Care Facilities Abroad]. Available on http://www.sueddeutsche.de/politik/pflege¬heime-im-ausland-die-verrueckte-idee-vom-greisen-export-1.1512615 (Accessed: May 08, 2018).
Rothgang, H., Müller, R. & Unger, R. (2012). Themenreport “Pflege 2030.” Was ist zu erwarten – was ist zu tun? [Themantic report “old age care 2030.” What to expect – What should be done?]. Available on https:// www.bertelsmann-stiftung.de/fileadmin/files/BSt/Publikationen/ GrauePublikationen/GP_Themenreport_Pflege_2030.pdf (Accessed: July 04, 2018).
Schneekloth, U. & Wahl, H.-W. (2009). Pflegebedarf und Versorgungssitua¬tion bei älteren Menschen in Heimen. Demenz, Angehörige und Freiwillige, Beispiele für “Good Practice” [Care Needs and the Care Situation of Older People in Residential Care. Dementia, Family Member and Volunteer, “Good Practive” Example]. Stuttgart: Kohlhammer.
Schweppe, C. (2005). Soziale Altenarbeit [Social work with elder people]. In W. Thole (ed.), Grundriss Soziale Arbeit. Ein einführendes Handbuch [Social Work. An Introductory Handbook] (pp. 331–348). Opladen: VS.
Schweppe, C. (2012). Altenarbeit: Altenhilfe, Altenpflege, Altenbildung [Old age care, old age education]. In: H.-H. Krüger & T. Rauschen¬bach (eds.), Einführung in die Arbeitsfelder des Bildungs- und Sozial¬wesens [Introduction to Fields of Social Work and Education] (5th ed., thoroughly revised and expanded revision, pp. 187–208). Opladen: Barbara Budrich.
Schwiter, K., Berndt, C. & Schilling, L. (2014). Ein sorgender Markt: Wie transnationale Vermittlungsagenturen für Seniorenbetreuung Im/ mobilität, Ethnizität und Geschlecht in Wert setzen. The Caring Market. How Transnational Recruitment Agencies Make Use of Im/mobility, Ethnicity and Gender). Geographische Zeitschrift 102(4): 212–231.
Schwiter, K., Berndt, C. & Truong, J. (2018). Neoliberal austerity and the marketization of elderly care. Social and Cultural Geography 19(3): 379–399.
Statistisches Bundesamt. (2015). 20 Jahre Pflegeversicherung: Immer mehr auf Hilfe zur Pflege angewiesen [20 Years of Long-Term Care Insurance: More and More People Depent on Care Support]. Available on https://www. destatis.de/DE/ZahlenFakten/ImFokus/Soziales/Pflegebeduerf-tigeSozialhilfe.html (Accessed: May 20, 2018).
Stiftung Warentest. (2017). Helferinnen aus dem Osten [Helpers from the East]. test.de: 88–94.
Stoffers, A. (2014). Thailand und Deutschland. Wirtschaft, Politik, Kultur [Thailand and Germany. Economy, Politics, Culture]. Berlin: Springer Verlag.
Strauss, A. & Corbin, J. (1996). Grounded Theory. Grundlagen qualitativer Sozialforschung [Foundations of Qualitative Research]. Weinheim: Beltz & Psychologie Verlags Union.
Suchman, M. C. (1995). Managing legitimacy: Strategic and institutional approaches. Academy of Management Journal 20(3): 571–610.
Thiesen, H. K. (n.d.). Altersruhesitz in Thailand [Retiring in Thailand]. Available on http://www.siam-info.de/auswandern/altersruhesitz.html (Accessed: January 21, 2019).
Toyota, M. & Thang, L. L. (2017). Transnational retirement mobility as processes of identity negotiation: The case of Japanese in South-east Asia. Identities 24(5): 557–572.
Toyota, M. & Xiang, B. (2012). The emerging transnational ‘retirement industry’ in Southeast Asia. The International Journal of Sociology and Social Policy 32(11/12): 708–719.
Walgenbach, P. & Meyer, R. (2008). Neoinstitutionalistische Organisationstheorie [Neoinstitutional Organization Theory]. Stuttgart: Verlag W. Kohlhammer.
Weingärtner, C. (2012). Darum ist Pflege so teuer. Gewalt im Altenheim – Angst vor Abschiebung ins Ausland [That Is Why Old Age Care Is So Expensive. Violence in Residential Old Age Care – The Fear of Being Deported Abroad]. Available on https://www.bild.de/ratgeber/2012/ pflegeversicherung/darum-ist-pflege-so-teuer-27216272.bild.html (Accessed: May 08, 2018).