Gender Arrangements and Pension Systems in Britain and Germany : Tracing change over five decades

Main Article Content

Traute Meyer
Birgit Pfau-Effinger

Abstract

This paper studies the modernisation of gender arrangements and the restructuring of pension systems in the United Kingdom and Germany since the 1950s. We firstly aim to pinpoint the time when pension programmes were apt components of the ’strong breadwinner model’. Secondly, we explore the assumption that pension systems are tools of stratification, by comparing the ways in which the constraints and incentives of these pension systems have been in line with typical life courses of women. Our paper argues that the constraints and incentives of pensions have altered quite significantly over time and questions whether they have appropriately been characterised as components of strong breadwinner models over the long term. In the UK the pension system only supported the strong breadwinner model until the mid-1970s, whilst the German system never fully supported it. In addition, it is shown that the impact of pensions on women’s behaviour is relatively limited. At times, women’s lives were in accordance with the male breadwinner model, and they suffered high poverty risks despite having potential access to a more modern pension regime; during other periods, their employment choices were at odds with the strong directives issued by pension regulations to stay at home. This demonstrates the importance of taking other factors, such as cultural influences and other societal institutions into account when exploring the impact of social policies on citizens’ lives; but it also poses the question of whether pensions are really important building blocks of the breadwinner model.

Metrics

Metrics Loading ...

Article Details

Section
Articles in a Special Issue

References

Anderson, K. & Meyer, T. (2003). Social Democracy, Unions, and Pension Politics in Germany and Sweden, Journal of Public Policy, 23(1): 23–55. [Read this article]


Anderson, K. & Meyer, T. (2004). The Third Way in Welfare State Reform? Social Democratic Pension Politics in Germany and Sweden. In Bonoli, Giuliano & Powell Martin (eds.), Social Democratic Party Policies in Contemporary Europé (pp. 141–160). Routledge.


Anderson, K. & Meyer, T. (2006). New social risks and pension reform in Germany and Sweden. The politics of pension rights for childcare. In Armingeon, K. & Bonoli, G. (eds.), Post Industrial Welfare States. Politics and Policies (pp. 171–191). Routledge.


AVmg (Altersvermögensgesetz) – Bundestagsdrucksache 14/4595: Gesetzentwurf der Fraktionen SPD und BÜNDNIS 90/DIE GRÜNEN: Entwurf eines Gesetzes zur Reform der gesetzlichen Rentenversicherung und zur Förderung eines kapitalgedeckten Altersvorsorgevermögens. 14.11.2000.


Baldwin, P. (1990). The Politics of Social Solidarity. Class Bases of the European Welfare State 1875–1975. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.


Baldwin, P. (2004). The worlds of welfare: illusory and gender blind?, Social Policy & Society 3:3, 201–211. [Read this article]


Bang, H.; Jensen, P. & Pfau-Effinger, B. (2000). Contextualization of gender policies of European welfare states’. In: Duncan, S. S. & Pfau-Effinger, B. (eds.), Gender, Work and Culture in the European Union. (pp. 115–142). London: Routledge,.


Barr, N. & Coulter, F. (1990). Social Security: Solution or Problem? In J. Hills (ed.), The State of Welfare. The Welfare State in Britain since 1974 (pp. 274–337). Oxford: Clarendon Press.


Beck, U., (1992). Risk Society: Towards a New Modernity. London, New York: Sage.


Bleses, P. (2003). Der Umbau geht weiter – Lohnarbeit und Familie in der rot-grünen Sozialpolitik, Zeitschrift für Sozialreform 49(4): 557–582.


Bonoli, G. (2003). Two Worlds of Pension Reform in Western Europé, Comparative Politics, 35:4, 399–416. [Read this article]


BSHG (Bundessozialhilfegesetz): http://bundesrecht.juris.de/bundesrecht/bshg/gesamt.pdf.


Bridgen, P. & Meyer, T. (2005). When do benevolent employers change their mind? Explaining the Retrenchment of Defined-benefit Pensions in Britain, Social Policy and Administration, 39(7): 764–785. [Read this article]


Busch, F. W.; Nauck, B. & Nave-Herz, R. (eds.) (1999). Aktuelle Forschungsfelder der Familienwissenschaft, Reihe Familie und Gesellschaft Bd. 1, Würzburg: Ergon.


Castles, F. G. (2003). The World Turned Upside Down: Below Replacement Fertility, Changing Preferences and Family-Friendly Public Policy in 21 OECD. Countries Journal of European Social Policy, 13(3): 209–227. [Read this article]


Clark, T. (2001). Recent Pensions Policy and the Pension Credit, Institute for Fiscal Studies, February 2001.


CM4179 (1998). A new contract for welfare: Partnership in Pensions. HMSO.


Cochrane, A. & Doogan, K. (1993). Welfare Policy: the Dynamics of European Integration, Policy and Politics 21(2): 85–95. [Read this article ]


 ‘Der Spiegel’, ‘Streit um die Riester-Rente. Jetzt kommen die Unisex-Tarife, von Hans Michael Koth, 27.4.2004.


Daly, M. (2000). The Gender Division of Welfare. The Impact of the British and German Welfare States. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.


Daune-Richard, A. M. (1998). How does the ’societal effect’ shape the use of part-time work in France, the UK and Sweden? In C. Fagan & J. O’Reilly (eds.), Part-time Prospects. London: Routledge.


Duncan, S. (1995). Theorizing European Gender Systems’ Journal of European Social Policy 5(4): 263–284. [Read this article]


DWP (Department for Work and Pensions) (1998). Employers’ Pension Provision 1998. A report of research carried out on behalf of the DWP. J. Hales; N. Stratford. Research Report No 123. HMSO.


DWP (2002). Employers’ Pension Provision 2000. A report of research carried out by the Policy Studies Institute on behalf of the DWP. A. Smith; S. McKay. Research Report No 163. HMSO.


DWP (2004). Employers’ Pension Provision 2003. A report of research carried out by the Centre for Research in Social Policy on behalf of the DWP. A. Cebulla; S. Reyes De-Beaman Research Report No 207. HMSO.


DWP (2006). Security in Retirement. Towards a New Pensions System. CM 6841.


Ellingsaeter, A., (1999). Dual Breadwinners between State and Market. In R. Crompton (ed.), Restructuring Gender Relations and Employment. The Decline of the Male Breadwinner. Oxford: Oxford University Press.


Esping-Andersen, G., (1990). The Three Worlds of Welfare Capitalism. Cambridge: Polity Press.


Esping-Andersen, G. 1999. Social Foundations of Postindustrial Economies. Oxford: Oxford University Press.


European Commission (1998). Care in Europe. Joint Report of the ‘Gender and Employment’ and the ‘Gender and Law’ Groups of Experts. Brüssel: European Commission.


Evason, E. & Spence, L. (2003). Women and Pensions: Time for a Rethink. Social Policy and Administration, 37(3): 253–270. [Read this article]


Fagan, C. Rubery, J. & Smith, M. 1999. Women’s Employment in Europe. Trends and Prospects. London/New York: Routledge.


Financial Times 21 May 2004; 11 December 2004 Expert sees public sector pension gap, 21.05.2004.


Foner, A. (1994). Endnote: The reach of an idea. In: Riley, M. W. u.a. (Hrsg.), Age and Structural Lag: Society’s failure to provide meaningful opportunities in work, family and leisure, New York: John H. Wiley & Sons.


Fox Harding, L., (1996). Family, State and Social Policy. London: Macmillan.


GAD (Governmen Actuary Department) (2003a). Occupational pension schemes 2000. Eleventh survey by the Government Actuary. April 2003, The Government Actuary’s Department. London: www.gad.gov.uk/Publications/docs/opss2000_final_results_final_7april2003.pdf


GAD (2003b). Occupational pension schemes 2000. Eleventh survey by the Government Actuary. Preliminary results for public sector schemes. February 2003. http://www.gad.gov.uk/Publications/docs/opss2000_Preliminary_Results_Public_14_Feb_2003.pdf.


GAD (2002). Occupational Pension Schemes 1995. Tenth Survey by the Government Actuary. London. www.gad.gov.uk.


Geissler, B. & Oechsle, M. (1996). Lebensplanung junger Frauen. Die widersprüchliche Modernisierung weiblicher Lebensläufe. Weinheim: Deutscher Studien-Verlag.


Gerhard, U. (1995). Die ‘langen’ Wellen der Frauenbewegung – Traditionslinien und unerledigte Anliegen. In: Becker-Schmidt, Regina & Knapp, Gudrun-Axeli (eds.), Das Geschlechterverhältnis als Gegenstand der Sozialwissenschaften, Frankfurt/M., pp. 247–278.


Ginn, J. (2003). Gender, Pensions and the Lifecourse. Bristol: Policy Press


Ginn, J. (2001). From Security to Risk. Pension Privatisation and gender inequality. A catalyst working paper. www.catalyst-trust.co.uk.


Goodin R. E.; Headey, B.; Muffels, A. & Dirven, H.-J. (1999). The real worlds of welfare capitalism. Cambridge : Cambridge University Press.


Groves, D. (1987). Occupational Pension provision and Women’s Poverty in Old Age. In Glendinning, C. & Millar, J. (eds.). Women and Poverty in Britain (pp. 199–220). Brighton: Wheatsheaf.


Groves, D. (1983). Members and Survivors: Women and Retirement-Pension Legislation. Lewis, J. (ed.), Women’s Welfare, Women’s Rights (18–63). Croom Helm: London & Canberra.


Hannah, L. (1986). Reinventing Retirement. The development of occupational pensions in Britain. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.


Hantrais, L. (1999). Socio-Demographic Change, Policy Impacts and Outcomes in Social Europe. Journal of European Social Policy 9(4): 291–309.


Heller, B. (2001). Die Neuregelungen des Altersvermögensgesetzes DAngVers 7/10:1–8. http://www.bfaberlin.de/ger/ger_nachschlagewerke.6/ger_dangvers.61/ger_ausgaben2001.613/ger_613_index.html.


Hentschel, V. (1983). Geschichte der deutschen Sozialpolitik (18801980). Frankfurt: edition Suhrkamp.


Hinrichs, K. (2003). Between Continuity and Paradigm Shift: Pension Reforms in Germany, Zentrum für Sozialpolitik, ZeS-Arbeitspapier Nr. 14/03, Universität Bremen: Bremen.


Honeyball, S. & Shaw, J. (1991). Sex, Law and the Retiring Man, European Law Review 14: 47–58.


IAB (2001). IAB Kurzbericht, Issue No. 7, 12.04.2001.


IDS (2003). Pensionsin practice 2003/04. From primary legislation to practical implementation. Incomes Data Services. London.


Kahn, R. L. (1994). Opportunities, Aspirations, and Goodness of Fit. In Riley, M.W. u.a. (Hrsg.): Age and Structural Lag: Societie’s Failure to provide meaningful opportunities in work, family and leisure. New York: John H. Wiley & Sons.


Kasza, G. (2002). The Illusion of Welfare ‘Regimes’, Journal of Social Policy 31(2): 271–287. [Read this article]


Knijn, T. & Kremer, M. (1997). Gender and the Caring Dimension of Welfare States: Toward Inclusive Citizenship, Social Politics 5: 328–361.


Kulawik, T. (1992). Das beste Sozialsystem der Welt? Sozialpolitik als Geschlechterpolitik in (West)Deutschland. In Joester, A. & Schöningh (I.) (eds.), So nah beieinander und doch so fern. Frauenleben in Ost und West. Pfaffenweiler: Centaurus Verlag: 105–125.


Land, H. (1985). Who Still Cares for the Family? Recent Developments in Income Maintenance. In Ungerson, Clare (ed.), Women and Social Policy. A Reader (50–62). MacMillan Publishers: Houndmills, Basingstoke.


Langen, H.-G. (2001). Die neue Rentenanpassung ab 1.7. 2001 DAngVers 7/10: 1–5 http://www.bfaerlin.de/ger/ger_nachschlagewerke.6/ger_dangvers.61/ger_ausgaben2001.613/ger_613_index.html.


Leira, A. (2002). Working Parents and the Welfare State. Family Change and Policy Reform in Scandinavia. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.


Lewis, J. (1992). Gender and the Development of Welfare Regimes, Journal of European Social Policy 2(3): 159–173. [Read this article]


Lewis, J. (2001). The decline of the malebreadwinner model: implications for work and care. Social Politics, 8(2), 152–170.


Lewis, J. & Ostner,I. (1994). Gender and the Evolution of European Social Policy. In Leibfried, S. & Pierson, P. (eds.), European Social Policy. Washington, D.C. Brookings Institute.


Lister, R. (2000). Citizenship and Gender. In Nash, K. & Scott, A. (eds.) The Blackwell companion to political sociology. Oxford: Blackwell.


Mazey, S. (1998). The European Union and Women’s Rights: From the Europeanization of National Agendas to the Nationalization of a European Agenda? Journal of European Public Policy 5(1): 131–152. [Read this article]


Meyer, T. (1998a). Retrenchment, Reproduction, Modernization: Pension Politics and the Decline of the German Breadwinner Model, Journal of European Social Policy, 8(3): 212–227. [Read this articl]


Meyer, T. (1998b). Die Erosion des starken deutschen Brotverdienermodells. Sozioökonomische und institutionelle Faktoren. Zeitschrift für Sozialreform, Issue 11/12, 818–838.


Meyer, T. (1997). Ungleich Besser? Die ökonomische Unabhängigkeit von Frauen im Zeichen der Expansion sozialer Dienstleistungen. Berlin: edition sigma.


Moeller, R.-G. (1993). Protecting Motherhood. Women and the Family in the Politics of Postwar West-Germany. University of California Press: Berkeley/Oxford.


Napf (2003). NAPF Annual Survey of Occupational Pension Schemes 2003; http://www.napf.co.uk/news/AnnualSurvey.cfm.


Neilson, J. (1998). Equal Opportunities for Women in the European Union: Success of Failure, Journal of European Social Policy 8 (1): 64–79. [Read this article]


OECD (2005). Pensions at a Glance. Public Policies across OECD Countries. 2005 Edition. Paris.


Offe, C. (1993). Zur Typologie von sozialpolitischen „Regimes“, Zeitschrift für Sozialreform 39(2): 83–86.


Opielka, M. (2002). Familie und Beruf. Eine deutsche Geschichte, Aus Politik und Zeitgeschichte B 22–23.


OPRA (2004). Occupational Pensions Schemes Regulatory Survey 2003. www.opra.gov.uk.


Orloff, A. S. (1993). Gender and social rights of citizenship: the comparative analysis of gender relations and welfare states, American Sociological Review, 58, 3030–28. [Read this article]


Pascall, G. (1986). Social Policy. A feminist Analysis. London.


Pascall, G. (1999). UK Family Policy in the 1990s: The case of New Labour and Lone Parents, International Journal of Law, Policy and the Family 13: 258–273. [Read this article]


Pensions Commission (2004). Pensions: Challenges and Choices. The First Report of the Pensions Commission. The Stationery Office. www.tso.co.uk/bookshop.


Pensions Policy Institute (2006). An evaluation of the White Paper state pension reform proposals, London, Pensions Policy Institute: http://www.pensionspolicyinstitute.org.uk/uploadeddocuments/Nuffield/PPI_evaluation_of_WP_state_pension_reforms_20_July_2006.pdf.


Pensions Advisory Service (2004). Report on Women and Pensions Helpline. 18 October – 10 December 2004. http://www.pensionsadvisoryservice.org.uk/publications/tpas_reports/Docs/WomenandPensionsReport.pdf.


Pfau-Effinger, B. (1998). Gender cultures and the gender arrangement – a theoretical framework for cross-national comparisons on gender. The Spatiality of Gender, Special Issue of Innovation: the European Journal of Social Sciences, ed. by S. Duncan, 11(2): 147–166.


Pfau-Effinger, B. (2004a). Development of Culture, Welfare States and Women’s Employment in Europe. Aldershot: Ashgate.


Pfau-Effinger, B. (2004b). Historical paths of the male breadwinner family model – explanation for cross-national differences, The British Journal for Sociology 55(3): 377–399. [Read this article]


Pfau-Effinger, B. (2005a). Culture and Welfare State Policies: Reflections on a Complex Interrelation, Journal of Social Policy 34(1): 1–18. [Read this article]


Pfau-Effinger, B. (2005b). Welfare State Policies, cultural differences and care arrangements. European Societies, 7(2): 321–347. [Read this article]


Pfau-Effinger, B. & Geissler, B. (2002). Cultural change and family policies in East and West Germany. In Carling, A.; Duncan, S. & Edwards, R. (eds.), Analysing Families: Morality and Rationality in Policy and Practice. London, New York: Routledge.


Pierson, P. (1994). Dismantling the Welfare State? Cambridge: CUP.


PMI (Pensions Management Institute) (2004): PMI News: The impact of anti-discrimination laws on occupational pensions. February 2004. http://www.pensions-pmi.org.uk/Publications/.


Prognos (1999). Versorgungslücken in der Alterssicherung: Privater Vorsorgebedarf für den Schutz im Alter, bei Erwerbsminderung und im Hinterbliebenenfall. Gutachten im Auftrag des Gesamtverbandes der Deutschen Versicherungswirtschaft, Basel.


Rake, K., Falkingham, J. and Evans. M. (2000). British Pension Policy in the Twenty-first Century: a Partnership in Pensions or a Marriage to the Means Test?, Social Policy and Administration, 34(3): 296–317. [Read this article]


Randall, V. (1987). Women and Politics. Palgrave Macmillan.


Riley, M. W. & Riley, J. W. (1994). Structural Lag: Past and Future. In Riley, M. W. u.a. (Hrsg.): Age and Structural Lag: Society’s failure to provide meaningful opportunities in work, family and leisure. New York: John H. Wiley & Sons.


Scharpf, F. W. (2000). The viability of advanced welfare states in the international economy: vulnerabilities and options, Journal of European Public Policy 7(2): 190–228. [Read this article]


Schmähl, W. (2004). Paradigm shift in German pension policy: measures aiming at a new public-private mix and their effects. In Rein, M. & Schmähl, W. (eds.), Rethinking the Welfare State – The Political Economy of Pension Reform (pp. 50–62) Cheltenham/UK ; Northampton/ MA, USA: Edward Elgar.


Schmidt, M. G. (1998). Sozialpolitik in Deutschland. Opladen: Leske & Budrich.


Seeleib-Kaiser, M. (2002). A Dual Transformation of the German Welfare State? West European Politics 25(4): 25–48. [Read this article]


Siim, B. (2000). Gender and Citizenship. Politics and Agency in France, Britain and Denmark. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.


Sinfield, A (2000). Tax Benefits in Non-State Pensions, European Journal of Social Security, Vol. 2, No. 2.


Standfest, Erich (2001). Bericht des Vorstandsvorsitzenden des VDR auf der Mitgliederversammlung am 15. Mai 2001 in Berlin. Worlaut der Rede. www.vdr.de, 21.6.2000.


Taylor-Gooby, P. (1996). Eurosclerosis in European Welfare States: Regime Theory and the Dynamics of Change, Policy and Politics 24(2): 109–124. [Read this article]


TNS Infratest (2005a). Situation und Entwicklung der betrieblichen Altersversorgung in Privatwirtschaft und öffentlichem Dienst 2001 – 2004,Endbericht. Untersuchung im Auftrag des Bundesministeriums für Gesundheit und Soziale Sicherung. Durchgeführt von TNS Infratest Sozialforschung München, 21. September, BE 50.37895.


TNS Infratest (2005b). Künftige Alterseinkommen der Arbeitnehmer mit Zusatzversorgung 2005, Endbericht. Untersuchung im Auftrag des Bundesministeriums für Gesundheit und Soziale Sicherung. Durchgeführt von Infratest Sozialforschung München, August 2005, BE 50.39505.


Veil, M. (2003). Alterssicherung von Frauen in Deutschland und Frankreich. Reformperspektiven und Reformblockaden. Berlin: edition sigma.